Should I Buy a New Electric Golf Trolley or Have It Repaired?

If your electric golf trolley is showing signs of wear and tear, you may be wondering whether to invest in a brand-new model or have your existing one repaired. This is a common dilemma for many golfers, particularly those who rely on their trolley to enhance their game and reduce physical strain. In this post, we explore the key factors to consider when making your decision.

1. Cost Comparison: Repair vs Replacement

The price of a new electric golf trolley can range from £400 to over £1,500, depending on the make, model, and features. In contrast, repairing a faulty trolley is often significantly cheaper, especially if the issue is minor—such as a battery replacement, a faulty motor, or a worn-out wheel.

At Golf Trolley Repairs UK, we work around a £350 price mark for repairs. If the repair cost exceeds £350, we may advise customers to consider purchasing a new trolley—provided they have a good working battery. For example, the Motocaddy SE (without battery) is a solid option, as it remains compatible with parts from earlier models such as the 2008 Motocaddy S1, ensuring a reliable and cost-effective solution.

2. Common Issues That Can Be Repaired

• Battery not holding charge – A replacement battery is considerably cheaper than a new trolley.
• Faulty speed controller – This is often a repairable component rather than requiring a full trolley replacement.
• Motor failure – While a new motor can be costly, it is usually still cheaper than purchasing a new trolley.
• Broken frame or wheels – Many structural components can be repaired or replaced.

3. How Old Is Your Trolley?

The age of your golf trolley is a key factor in determining whether it is worth repairing. High-quality electric trolleys (such as those from Motocaddy, Powakaddy, and other leading brands) are built to last 5–10 years with appropriate maintenance.

However, if your trolley is more than 7–10 years old and has multiple worn-out components, it may be time to consider an upgrade. That said, many older models, such as the 2008 Motocaddy S1, can still function perfectly with the right repairs, as all parts are still available.

4. Are You Looking for New Features?

If your existing trolley lacks modern features such as GPS, USB charging, or improved battery efficiency, upgrading to a new model may be beneficial. However, if your current trolley meets your needs and only requires a minor fix, investing in a new model may not be necessary.

5. Environmental Considerations

Repairing your golf trolley rather than replacing it is the more environmentally friendly choice. Disposing of an old trolley contributes to electronic waste, whereas repairing and maintaining it helps reduce your carbon footprint.

6. Warranty & Support

If your trolley is still under warranty, repairs may be covered by the manufacturer. Even if it is out of warranty, reputable repair services can offer a cost-effective solution with their own guarantee on parts and labour.

Final Verdict: Repair or Replace?

Repair Your Trolley If:

• The issue is minor or a single component needs replacing.
• The cost of repair is significantly less than buying a new one.
• The trolley is under 5–7 years old and in generally good condition.
• You want to reduce environmental waste.
• You have a reliable older model (such as the Motocaddy SE/S1) that still has all parts available for maintenance.

Buy a New Trolley If:

• Your trolley is over 7–10 years old and has multiple faults.
• You want upgraded features that your current model lacks.
• The repair cost exceeds £350 and you already have a good working battery, making a new model like the Motocaddy SE (without battery) a viable option.

Need a Repair? We Can Help!

At Golf Trolley Repairs UK, we specialise in fast, cost-effective repairs for all major brands, including Motocaddy and Powakaddy. If your trolley can be fixed for under £350, we’ll get it back to perfect working order. If repairs exceed this price, we’ll guide you towards the best replacement options—especially if your battery is still in good condition.

Get in touch today for a free quote!